Saundarya Lahari
Saundarya Lahari
SAUNDARYA LAHARI - VERSE 76
- Details
- Written by Patrick Misson
- Parent Category: Content
- Hits: 13001
SAUNDARYA LAHARI
.
VERSE 76
THE PARAMETER CONTINUES BELOW THE O POINT FROM THE DIVING OF EROS BELOW THE O POINT
हरक्रोध-ज्वालावलिभि-रवलीढेन वपुषा
गभीरे ते नाभीसरसि कृतसङो मनसिजः ।
समुत्तस्थौ तस्मा-दचलतनये धूमलतिका
जनस्तां जानीते तव जननि रोमावलिरिति
gabhire te nabhi sarasi krtasango manasijah
samuttasthau tasmad acala tanaye dhuma latika
janastam janite janani tava romavalir iti
In the fire of Shiva's ire, into the deep lake of Your navel,
O Mountain Daughter, he dived, and on re-emerging,
The smoke thus raised, the people look upon as Your rows of hair.
.
.
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS WITH STRUCTURAL DIAGRAMS RELATED TO THIS VERSE FROM SAUNDARYA LAHARI/NOTES.
Hara krodha jvala vali bhih - by the collection of glances of fire/by the ensembles of the glances of fire of the anger of Hara
Avalidhena vapusha - with body permeated through and through
Gabhire te nabhi sarasi - in the deep navel-lake of thine
Krta sangah - one who has submerged himself
Manasijah samuttasthau - Eros rising up
Tasmad - from it (from this sinking)
Achala tanaye - o Daughter of the Hills
Dhuma latika - smoke streak
Janah stam - people, them
Janite - treat it like
Janani tava roma valir iti - o Mother, to be Your hairy ensembles (Mount Tamalpais) (sic - see the Guru's autobiography, page 620, Adventures in Inner and Outer Space. referring to Hippie Midsummer orgies on Mount Tamalpais. ED)
Another version:
Hara krodha jvala vali bhih - by the encircling flames of the ire of Shiva
Avalidhena vapusha - with body engulfed
Gabhire te nabhi sarasi - in the profound navel lake of Yours
Krtah sangah - having dived
Manasi jaha samuttasthau - the mind-born god Eros emerged therefrom
Tasmat - by that reason
Achala tanaye - daughter of the mountain
Dhuma latika - the creeper-like streaks of smoke
Janas tam - them, the people
Janite - they take to be
Janani tava roma valih iti - o Mother as Your rows of hairs
Uha-poha: That intuitive faculty which is akin to imagination or insight, or even critical acumen which, like statesmanship, chivalry or even craftsmanship is a gift with which certain persons are more endowed than others. It is more than what mere scholarship can give.
Ripples on the river seem to be a slight disturbance on the horizontal when it is met by the vertical.
The waist is referred to also as slim - it is a kind of parameter.
"There are some people with great insight who will see something very slender at Your navel, and will see a slight delicate interplay, like ripples.
The hollow of Your navel is filled with these; and that is where the attenuated space from between the breasts is entering".
When noumenal (positive) meets phenomenal (negative, perceptible by the senses or through immediate experience), there is a delicate touch of ripples such as found on the surface of a river when a gentle breeze blows.
The milk ocean is at a certain level.
Narayana; One who sleeps on the primordial waters (Nara, water; ayana, to lie in repose). Creation, before Brahma gave it the four directions, symbolized by his four heads, has the indefinite nature of all-pervading water ("God moved upon the face of the waters" as Genesis, I, 2 puts it) on which the numinous principle of life or creation was supposed to recline. ED).
Why is there fire suddenly at the area of the navel?
Because this man, Eros, is suffering from the contradiction of actualization.
But when you get to the Denominator, perceptual factors are mutually exclusive - the character of the vertical axis is now changed from water to fire.
When a man is erotic, he is likely to be pushing out some rival.
Eros is an entity belonging to that level, so he cannot sink forever.
He has a degree of immortality, and so he has to come back onto the scene.
He has to come there week by week.
This brings out the rahman-rahim aspect of the Absolute (Arabic, "(Allah) the merciful, the compassionate"see Quran).
- بِسْمِ اللهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيْمِ
- bismi-llāhi r-raḥmāni r-raḥīm
SAUNDARYA LAHARI - VERSE 77
- Details
- Written by Patrick Misson
- Parent Category: Content
- Hits: 15896
SAUNDARYA LAHARI
.
VERSE 77
FINE STRUCTURALIZED SPACE
यदेतत्कालिन्दी-तनुतर-तरङ्गाकृति शिवे
कृशे मध्ये किञ्चिज्जननि तव यद्भाति सुधियाम् ।
विमर्दा-दन्योन्यं कुचकलशयो-रन्तरगतं
तनूभूतं व्योम प्रविशदिव नाभिं कुहरिणीम्
krse maddhye kincijjanani tava yad bhati sudhiyam
vimardad anyonyamkucakalasayor antaragatam
tanubhutam vyoma pravisad iva nabhim kuharinim
Looking like ripples on the surface of the river Kalindi,
Looms in the mind of contemplatives as space reduced to ethereal particles
Entering into the cavity of Your navel, and produced by the friction of Your pot-like breasts.
("There is also non-Euclidian space, projective space, scalar space, topological space, vectorial space, as also the structure of space as understood by Minkowski, Lobachevsky and Riemann". In mathematics non-Euclidean geometry is a small set of geometries based on axioms closely related to those specifying Euclidean Geometry The essential difference between the metric geometries is the nature of parallel lines. Another way to describe the differences between these geometries is to consider two straight lines indefinitely extended in a two-dimensional plane that are both perpendicular to a third line.
- In Euclidean geometry the lines remain at a constant distance from each other even if extended to infinity, and are known as parallels.
- In hyperbolic geometry they "curve away" from each other, increasing in distance as one moves further from the points of intersection with the common perpendicular; these lines are often called ultraparallels.
- In elliptic geometry the lines "curve toward" each other and intersect. ED)
-
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS WITH STRUCTURAL DIAGRAMS RELATED TO THIS VERSE FROM SAUNDARYA LAHARI/NOTES.
Yadetat - gleaming (with a sheen)
Kalindi tanutara taranga krtih - of the form of the slender or fine ripples on the surface of the river Kalindi
Shive - o Shiva-consort
Krshe madhye - with thin middle part
Kimchit - something
Janani - mother
Tava yat - that which is Yours
Bhati sudhiyam - to learned and good devotees it shines (as)
Vimardad anyonyam kucha kala shayoh - by mutual impact of the water-pot-shaped breasts
Antara gatam - what lies between
Tanu bhutam vyomam - made into a thin, schematic factor (sky-space: "bhutam vyomam")
Pravishad iva - as if entering
Nabhim kuharinim - the navel, an orifice or opening
Another version:
Yad etat - this which is here seen
Kalindi tanu tara taranga krti - having the form of superfine ripples on the river Kalindi
Shive - o Shiva consort
Krshe madhye - at Your slender middle region
Kinchit - that something
Janani - o Mother
Tava yad - Yours which is
Bhati sudhiyam - looms in the mind of contemplatives
Vimardat anyonyam kucha kala shayoh - reduced by the friction of Your pot-like breasts
Antara gatam - entering inside (the cavity of the navel)
Tanu bhutam vyoma - pure space reduced to ethereal particles
Pravishad iva nabhim - as if entering into the cavity of the navel
Kuharinim - which has a hollow cavity.
The Devi is here treated as a universal concrete.
There is no major difficulty in its treatment.
The surface picture is of an affiné river.
This is Eddington's physical world, exponential mathematics.
It is pure mathematical contemplation, abstracted and generalized.
The four dimensions become abstract at the waist where there is only a vertical vertebral column.
There is no psycho-physical communication except through the Susumna - the extremely thin central nadi or passage.
This is gynaecological schematismus.
Above are some examples of Minkowskian Space
..
Also, below, the colour solid:
.
.
Other examples of the same structure, with different applications:
Minkowski Space.
.
The Devi's garland between her breasts is a hyperbola coming from the other side of the universe, like Halley's comet, which appears, then goes to the other side of the universe.
When schematism (i.e. structuralism) is known to you with all its dynamisms, you become a wise man, your consciousness becomes like that of a baby in the womb, verticalized in Lobachevskian space. You know your past and your future, what it is possible to do with yourself and what is not possible.
O consort of Shiva
With thin middle part (waist)
Something (which resembles the shining of the ripples)
O Mother
That which is yours
To learned and good devotees it shines (as)
By mutual harsh contact (impact)of the water-pot-like shaped breasts
What lies between
The sky-space made into a thin string (schematic factor), (reduced into the vertical)
As if entering the navel /orifice leading into (navel), (the sky which has been pulverised by the two breasts, enters into the navel)
SAUNDARYA LAHARI - VERSE 78
- Details
- Written by Patrick Misson
- Parent Category: Content
- Hits: 14909
SAUNDARYA LAHARI
VERSE 78
THE O POINT WITH FOURFOLD POLYVALENCE
स्थिरो गङ्गा वर्तः स्तनमुकुल-रोमावलि-लता
कलावालं कुण्डं कुसुमशर तेजो-हुतभुजः ।
रते-र्लीलागारं किमपि तव नाभिर्गिरिसुते
बेलद्वारं सिद्धे-र्गिरिशनयनानां विजयते
kalavalam kundam kusuma sara tejo huta bhujah
rater lilagaram kim api tava nabhir girisute
biladvaram siddher girisa nayananam vijayate
As a stilled gangetic whirlpool, as the fecund flowerbed of Your breast-bud-bearing creeper
As the sacrificial fire-pit for Kama, and for Rati as her pleasure- bower
While to the eyes of the Mountain Lord the cavern mouth for his austerities
.
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS WITH STRUCTURAL DIAGRAMS RELATED TO THIS VERSE FROM SAUNDARYA LAHARI/NOTES.
Sthiro ganga vartah - the permanent whirlpool of the Ganges it is (Thou art)
Stana mukula roma valilata kala valam - the bed of fecundity for the hairy creeper bearing the buds of breasts
Kundam kusuma shara tejo huta bhujah - the fire sacrifice receptacle where the bright glory of the god of flower arrow is offered
Rateh lila garam - a house (or ground) for the play of Rati, the female counterpart of Eros
Kim api - somehow or other (by hook...)
Tava nabhih giri sute - Your navel, o Daughter of the Mountain
Bilad varam siddhah girisha nayanam vijayate - of the Lord of the Mountain, the door of the subterranean hole for the
.....(ILLEGIBLE)...psychic prowess, in the eye of Shiva.
Sthiro ganga vartah - still Gangetic whirlpool
Stana mukula roma vali lata kala valam - as the flower-bed for the creeper of lines of hair for which Your breasts are buds
Kundam kusuma shara tejo huta bhujah - the sacrificial fire-pit for receiving the offerings of the glory of Eros.
Rateh lila garam - for Rati her pleasure bower
Kim api - and as what not
Tava nabhir giri sute - o daughter of the peak, Your navel
Bilad varam siddhah girisha nayananam vijayate - to the eyes of Shiva the cave for austerities to bear fruit
Vijayate - it reigns supreme
-
The bed of fecundity for the hair creeper bearing the buds of breasts
The fire sacrifice receptacle wherein the bright glory of the god of flower arrow is offered
House (or ground) for the play of the female companion of the god Eros
Somehow or other (by hook or by crook)
Your navel, o Daughter of the Mountain.
- think of the whirlpool of Her navel and a kundam (sacrificial pit) as the same thing - the source of Eros.
Histology says that milk comes from the hair of the body.
All this fire and passion is the negative Absolute, which can destroy.
SAUNDARYA LAHARI - VERSE 79
- Details
- Written by Patrick Misson
- Parent Category: Content
- Hits: 10585
SAUNDARYA LAHARI
VERSE 79
PRECARIOUS VACUITY AT THE O POINT
निसर्ग-क्षीणस्य स्तनतट-भरेण क्लमजुषो
नमन्मूर्ते र्नारीतिलक शनकै-स्त्रुट्यत इव ।
चिरं ते मध्यस्य त्रुटित तटिनी-तीर-तरुणा
समावस्था-स्थेम्नो भवतु कुशलं शैलतनये
naman murter nari tilaka sanakais trutyata iva
ciram te maddhyasya trutita tatini tira taruna
samavasthastemno bhavatu kusalam saila tanaye
Bending by form and on the point of breaking,
Equal in state to a tree on a collapsing brook bank;
O mountain-born one, let there be security forever.
-
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS WITH STRUCTURAL DIAGRAMS RELATED TO THIS VERSE FROM SAUNDARYA LAHARI/NOTES.
Nisarga kshinasya - by nature (weakened or thinned, emaciated)
Stana tata bharena klamajusoh - by the weight of the heaving breasts attaining to fatigue
Naman murteh - with form bending down
Nari tilaka - perfected spot of womanly beauty
Shanakaih trutyta iva - as if about to break
Chiram - for long years
Te madhyasya - in the middle region of thine
Trutita tatini tira taruna - resembling a tree on the bank of a brook slid down
Sama vastah stemnah - having a firmness equal to it
Bhavatu kushalam - let it bless
Shaila tanaye - o daughter of the mountain.
.
Naman murteh - with form bowing down
Nari tilaka - o crowning forehead red mark of perfection of womanhood
Shanakais trutya iva - as if broken a little
Chiram - for long
Te madhyasya - of Your middle part
Trutita tatini tira taruna - broken (slid down, disrupted)
brook bank tree as comparable to
Sama vastha themnah - having resemblances
Bhavatu kushalam - let it bring blessings
Shaila tanaye - o Daughter of the Mountain
.
By nature (weakened or thinned - or emaciated)
By the weight of the heaving breasts attaining to fatigue
With form bending down (prostrating)
O perfect spot of womanly beauty (the spot placed by Indian women between the eyebrows)
As if about to break (one part of the breast from the other) (see structure)
For long years
In the middle region of thine (see structure)
Resembling a tree on a brook bank sliding down
Having a firmness equal to it
Let it bless
O Daughter of the Himalayas
Let the devotee attain long years of bliss by meditating on the middle part of this Goddess.
It is a tragic line about to break.
By the weight of breasts' bank (like the bank of a river)
What has become fatigued
With the form recumbent (as in humility or prayer)
O crowning forehead red mark of perfection of women (nari tilaka).
As if broken a little (peripherally broken, but within still intact)
For long (let this meditation give contemplative content...)
Of Your middle part
Broken (slid down or disrupted) brook bank tree as comparable
To hyper-fecundity in the nature of woman)
(A mound has been formed on which a tree can grow)
Let the devotee think of this comparison
Having resemblances (by the analogy )
Let it bring blessings, O Daughter of the Mountain
With form bowing down
O perfected woman (a tired woman is the perfect lover).
As if broken
For long
Of your middle part
As comparable to the broken brook-bank tree
They have got equality or resemblance (with Your middle part)
Let this meditation on this resemblance bring peace (a vision of the Absolute)
The banks are eroding on both sides, and on one of them is a tree, precariously standing.
There is a precarious part of a woman's body where the child is born: inside the mind of every woman there is this uncertainty.
The tree is about to fall; the child is about to come out: "My father did not even know me, and my mother could not do anything."
Verticality is life, and it is about to fall down; that is why the baby is meditating.
The beginnings of life are based on a precarious horizontal uncertainty.
Horizontalism is exclusive - the collapsing sides allow nothing to grow.
Precariousness = projective geometry.
SAUNDARYA LAHARI - VERSE 80
- Details
- Written by Patrick Misson
- Parent Category: Content
- Hits: 13586
SAUNDARYA LAHARI
VERSE 80
FULL HORIZONTALITY WITH A THIN MIDDLE GROUND
RECIPROCITY BETWEEN HORIZONTAL DEVELOPMENT AND VERTICAL THINNESS
SPEED GLOWS - TIME SHRINKS
RECIPROCITY BETWEEN THE HORIZONTAL AND THE VERTICAL
THE LIMIT OF HORIZONTALITY IMPLIES THE LIMIT OF VERTICALITY
कुचौ सद्यः स्विद्य-त्तटघटित-कूर्पासभिदुरौ
कषन्तौ-दौर्मूले कनककलशाभौ कलयता ।
तव त्रातुं भङ्गादलमिति वलग्नं तनुभुवा
त्रिधा नद्ध्म् देवी त्रिवलि लवलीवल्लिभिरिव
O Goddess, having made Your twin breasts gain the beauty of gold pots,
Rubbing at the upper arms, bursting the bodice and presently perspiring,
The God of Love, now wanting to save your threefold waist from breaking, saying : "enough"
With three strands of a wild creeper, he presently binds.
kucau sadyah svidyat tata ghatitakurpasabhidurau
kasantau dormule kanaka kalasabhau kalayata
tava tratum bhangad alam iti valagnam tanu bhuva
triddha naddham devi trivali lavalivallibhir iva
The predicament found in Verse 79 is here presented in a slightly more accentuated form. Here, what makes the danger worse is not womanhood in itself, but the factor of eroticism personified, the god of love. Womanly nature in itself is not responsible for the exaggeration of certain tendencies that become accentuated at certain times within the scope of the total personality of the Goddess. When a mature mango drops to the ground, it is not considered an advantage from the standpoint of the tree itself. Horizontalization involves an accentuation of certain tendencies at the expense of others. If one should lop off the side branches of a tree, the main branch will gain in strength from the extra sap available for its growth upward. The pruning of trees implies the recognition of such a complementary principle of growth. In cultivating a frail plant, like a tomato, the intelligent gardener often clips away the side branches and retains the main one. When the plant becomes fully laden with fruit, the careful gardener supports the frail stem by binding it to a stick to keep it upright. The heavy weight of the fruit might tend to snap the vertical stem, which is the disaster implied here.
The function of maternity is directly proportionate to the function of natural eroticism operating within the harmonized system of normal womanhood. Maternity is not a sin because of its libidinous implications. Sex is only a sin in the eyes of an angry God in the Garden of Eden, where it is referred to as a “forbidden fruit”. This does not mean that there is no place for an eroticism that is fully human and natural. The Bhagavad Gita allows for this by saying that when sex does not violate the norms of right conduct and is fully compatible with human nature in its basic tendencies, which it must share with all living beings, it is a kind of kama, or passion which is to be identified with the principle of the Absolute itself. This principle is represented by Krishna in the Bhagavad Gita, who says, “I am myself pure passion of this kind” (VII: 11), thus taking away the sense of guilt from eroticism. Although Semitic and prophetic religions have denounced sex; in the “Song of Solomon”, erotic mysticism is seen to be allowed as it is in the “Gita Govindam”and other works openly based on erotic mysticism in India.
Krishna stealing the clothes of gopis (female cowherds) and hiding in the trees is a favourite Rajput theme emblazoned on tapestries which are still admired in modern drawing rooms in the West. Here, beauty is the subject, not sin. Thus, Eros is admitted as a sufficiently dignified functionary in this work, as we have already seen as early as Verses 5 and 6. In fact, there are two rival functions to be recognized here: one in charge of horizontalizing tendencies, and the other which is normal to womanhood. Eroticism can assert itself strongly or lightly in different types of women, in the same way that both Ganesa and Subrahmanya could escape the carnal aspect of life. In womanhood especially, the accentuation of vitalistic tendencies can never be considered as a drawback. No cow could be bad because it gives milk as a result of its vitalism. Jesus would not curse a fig tree except for its sterility. What is a virtue with Shiva need not necessarily be a virtue with Parvati.
We notice that the God of Love is the maker of the horizontalized maturation of the two breasts, which are said to rub against the upper arms because of their fullness.
The bursting of the bodice is reminiscent of the nurse Peggotty in Dickens' "David Copperfield", whose buttons are said to be bursting each time she embraces the boy; so this is an old joke not unknown to English literature. Perspiration is also an indication of an extreme erotic state of mind, as referred to in Kalidasa's "Shakuntala". While, on one hand Kama accentuates horizontal “sin”; on the other, he is much concerned about the danger of the waist snapping when overladen with heavy fruit. The beauty here consists of the delicate interplay between tragic and comic elements, neither of which is allowed to predominate and spoil the balance or harmony. Before the last straw enters into the situation which he himself induced horizontally, Kama steps in saying, “enough!”. In order to keep the stem from breaking he props it up and binds it with three strands of a wild creeper, so that it could still stand erect. The three strands represent the three levels through which verticality has to pass to transcend the over-accentuation of any one of them. The way of transcending the three nature modalities (gunas) has been examined already in Verses 53 and 54. What applies there at a high level should also apply, by extrapolation, at the lower level of the middle region of the waist. The gold pots under reference here are found also in Kalidasa's poetry in the context of watering plants to help their growth. Compared with ruby pots, these might suggest a lower position in the hierarchical scale of values. Here it is not solidity that counts, but the golden coloration or brightness (abha).
Bhagavad Gita, Chapter VII:
Verse 11
balam balavatam cha'ham
kamaraga vivarjitam
dharmaviruddho bhuteshu
kamo 'smi bharatarshabha
I am the strength of the strong, devoid of desire
and passion. In beings I am desire which is not
contrary, to righteousness (dharma) 0 Leader of
the Bharatas (Arjuna).
.
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS WITH STRUCTURAL DIAGRAMS RELATED TO THIS VERSE FROM SAUNDARYA LAHARI/NOTES.
The positive over-generosity of life requires protection from the god of vitality.
Sadya svidyat tata ghatita kurpasa bhidurau - bursting the brassiere which has just been put on them while perspiring
Kashantau dormule - pressing on the armpit region
Kanaka kalasha abhau - having the lustre of golden water pots
Kalayata - manufactured, made
Tava - Your
Tratum - to save
Bhangat alam iti - saying "Do not!" - from being broken up
Valagnam - the middle region
Tanu bhuva tridha naddham - by three rounds (loops) has bound, the god of love
Devi - Devi
Tri vali lavali valli bhih - by triple branch creeper of Lavali creeper
Iva - as if
.
Another version is:
Kuchau - the pair of breasts
Sadyah svidya tata ghatita kurpasa bhidurau - bursting the knotted bodice and presently perspiring
Kashantau dormule - rubbing at the upper arms
Kanaka kala shabau - having the brilliance of twin golden pots
Kalayata - he who makes
Tava tratum - these Yours to save
Bhangat - from breaking
Alam iti - saying enough
Valagnam - the mid region
Tanu bhuvatridha naddham - the god of love has bound by three-fold strands
Devi - Goddess
Triva lila vallibhih - by three strands of a wild creeper
Iva - it would seem
Another version:
1 - The twin breasts
2 - Bursting the brassiere that has just been bound on them while perspiring
3 - Pressing on the armpits region
4 - Having the lustre of golden water pots
5 - Manufactured, made
6 - Your
7 - To save
8 - Saying : "Do not!" - from being broken up
9 - The middle region
10 - By three rounds has bound the God of Love
11 - Devi
12 - By triple-branched creeper of Lavali
13 - As if
2 - Perspiring - representing the Universal Absolute. Shiva the husband, watches as Eros is the cause of the perspiration.
The brassiere is just put on, and the breasts are bursting through it - a PRESENT erotic picture.
3 - The breasts want to burst in every direction, not just forward
4 - In the West the breasts would be called "ivory"
5 - Breasts are not made by the woman herself. Eros has entered into Her as a horizontal factor and manufactured this state.
6 - "Your" refers to the middle region of the Devi
7 - To save - Eros feels responsible
8 - Saying...any more eroticism will burst the middle
9 - the middle region
10 - Eros has said: "If You act like this, I am going to bind Your middle with three strands".
He is concerned.
Concern is thus directed towards binding the middle and....(ILLEGIBLE)
There is vertical binding to prevent the horizontal from flying apart.
Eros binds by three bindings - to unite it organically with a lower pole - to prevent breaking at the waist.
This is realistically analyzed from the point of view of Eros, as an agent of biological, hierophantic functions on the negative side; he is not in charge of the origin of the creeper, but only of the binding.
(Note the correspondence with Verse 69. ED)
The breasts are sometimes golden pots, sometimes ruby pots: see VERSE 73.
Her two chidren are drinking milk from Her breasts:
Subrahmanya is in Ajna Chakra,
The point is: within the personality of the Devi there are two kinds of hardness: diamond hardness on the negative side, and hydrogen-flame "hardness" on the Numerator side.
One increases with the other, thus the crowns are whetstones; there is a cancellability between the nails and the crowns.
The bipolarity between the ontological and the teleological is brought out here, absolute hardness does not reside in any one part of the body.
The vertical axis is happiness, the horizontal axis is suffering: teach people to adjust their insides; you will do them a great service.
Whatever god they give you, ask for his functions and place him mathematically in a schema.
The contribution of Vedanta: svadharma ("your own dharma" - karma verticalized) is to be cultivated from the Denominator side, do not try and pick your svadharma from the Numerator side.
Start from the side of cause, and work upwards to your own spiritual progress.
Do not try to descend from above, do not put too much emphasis on the prophetic side.